Advertisement
I'm about 1/3 of the way through this one because the real time book club I'm in is reading it as this month's selection. One woman in the group read it and loved it. My best friend actually gave me a copy not knowing it was this month's selection.
I'm finding it pretty trite. The author has her struggles with depression and I suppose tries to overcompensate by being funny or clever but it doesn't work for me. Maybe I've been reading too much Doris Lessing. I like something with much more depth. After coming off several books by Lessing with her towering intellect, this book seems like pure fluff. Or maybe I'm now too old for things written by young women? Or maybe it IS just fluff. I'd like to hear any other opinions on it. I'm looking forward to getting into her story about India and also working with the Indonesian shaman. Those topics are more up my alley, so to speak. But I don't look forward to forcing myself through this book to get to those chapters.
I'm finding it pretty trite. The author has her struggles with depression and I suppose tries to overcompensate by being funny or clever but it doesn't work for me. Maybe I've been reading too much Doris Lessing. I like something with much more depth. After coming off several books by Lessing with her towering intellect, this book seems like pure fluff. Or maybe I'm now too old for things written by young women? Or maybe it IS just fluff. I'd like to hear any other opinions on it. I'm looking forward to getting into her story about India and also working with the Indonesian shaman. Those topics are more up my alley, so to speak. But I don't look forward to forcing myself through this book to get to those chapters.
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Re: Eat, Pray, Love
Sun, June 8, 2008 - 7:42 AMI was just checking out Doris Lessing...which book do you recommend for my first read? -
-
Doris Lessing
Sun, June 8, 2008 - 11:44 PMShikasta is a good one! I also enjoyed Marriage Between the Zones... You don' t have to read the series in order. They don't relate much at all to each other. Mind you, her writing is pretty heavy stuff. I learned a lot when I read that book, though. I think my spiritual beliefs are pretty close to hers. She was a follower of a Sufi teacher named Inayat Khan, if I remember correctly. It's real late and my brain doesn't function when I'm tired. Better hit the hay. -
-
Eat Pray Love
Fri, June 13, 2008 - 10:38 PMI read Eat, Pray, Love. I liked it. I know a LOT of people that liked it but once it became a HUGE success they had a different opinion. That really irks me. I was thoroughly entertained by this little book. I was grateful when she really got into her travels cuz I was pretty annoyed with her obsession with her failed marriage. But, I haven't been through that kinda thing so maybe it is annoying and does last 5 years or whatever.
The book didn't change my life or anything. But, I certainly wish I could write like that. And travel like that. And eat like that! -
-
Re: Eat Pray Love
Sat, June 14, 2008 - 1:33 PMOkay, well I did enjoy her description of Italy and the people and the food. I, too, am envious of her for getting to do that. I guess it's just her lack of life experience, or inability to think a little deeper on things that bothers me. I'm now into the part where she's in India at the ashram. I majored in philosophy with a minor in religious studies. I studied a LOT of Hinduism and read the entire Bhagavad Gita with comments from my class and professor. I've meditated for years, practiced yoga, continued reading, and flirted with taking a guru on myself, including hers. She starts off saying she is keeping her guru secret but she drops enough hints that anyone who has been around knows exactly who her guru is. I just find her statements about mantras, kundalini energy, etc. to be trite, as well--as if she's not willing to properly research her topics. I'd be happier if she'd keep to her personal experience and not go where she's not well equipped to handle the subject. I'm surprised at myself on this one. I usually enjoy whatever we read in the book group I belong to and am pretty easygoing about things. But this one bothers me. Maybe I'm getting old. Ha. -
-
Re: Eat Pray Love
Sun, June 15, 2008 - 9:20 AMI can relate. When I reading it I was thinking that for some people this book will be like the "Celestine Prophesy". A little introduction to another way of thinking or living. One they may have never have thought of before. So, in that way I think it's great, appealing to the masses to be kinder, gentler and do some yoga!
-
-
-
-
-
Re: Eat, Pray, Love
Sun, June 22, 2008 - 2:50 PMAlright, alright! I take it all back! I just finished this book this morning and I loved it! I'm glad I stuck with it, motivated only because we'll be discussing it in the reading group meeting.
I fell in love with the author somewhere in her tales of her experience of India. She WAS self-absorbed, trite, fluff until she spent a certain amount of time in India. That was the whole point of her book--her transformation, and the balance she achieved via her travels. She DID end up going deep. I ended up totally admiring her. I can now recommend this book.
-
Re: Eat, Pray, Love
Sun, August 10, 2008 - 12:49 AMI'm currently reading it. I just started it and am about half way done with it. I find it fascinating but i'm into spiritual, travel, memoir sort of books. But I'm loving it. It's a fun read and not super deep I agree with that but it's good for a summer book.